fbpx
Technology

Energy Cost Of ‘Mining’ Bitcoin More Than Twice That Of Copper Or Gold

The amount of energy required to “mine” one dollar’s worth of bitcoin is more than twice that required to mine the same value of copper, gold or platinum, according to a new paper, suggesting that the virtual work that underpins bitcoin, ethereum and similar projects is more similar to real mining than anyone intended.

One dollar’s worth of bitcoin takes about 17 megajoules of energy to mine, according to researchers from the Oak Ridge Institute in Cincinnati, Ohio, compared with four, five and seven megajoules for copper, gold, and platinum.

Other cryptocurrencies also fair poorly in comparison, the researchers write in the journal Nature Sustainability, ascribing a cost-per-dollar of 7MJ for ethereum and 14MJ for the privacy focused cryptocurrency monero.

But all the cryptocurrencies examined come off well compared with aluminium, which takes an astonishing 122MJ to mine one dollar’s worth of ore.

“Mining” is the name for the process by which blockchains, such as those that underpin cryptocurrencies, are regulated and verified. In bitcoin’s case, for instance, the currency is backed by “miners” due to the absence of a centralised authority confirming transactions.

These miners effectively enter a competition to waste the most electricity possible by doing pointless arithmetic quintillions of times a second.

One lucky competitor wins both a reward, worth about eighty thousand dollars in bitcoin, and the right to verify all transactions made in the last 10 minutes.

The rewards may be virtual, but the energy cost is very real. Previous attempts to gauge how much electricity is burned to power the bitcoin network, still the largest blockchain in existence, have focused on looking at the size of the network in aggregate.

In November 2017, one estimate placed the power consumption of the network as equivalent to that of the nation of Ireland. Another noted it was producing the same annual carbon emissions as one million transatlantic flights.

The new paper is the first to look at the mining efforts from the point of view of energy cost per dollar benefit.

“The comparison is made to quantify and contextualise the decentralised energy demand that the mining of these cryptocurrencies requires,” the authors write, “and to encourage debate on whether these energy demands are both sustainable and appropriate given the product that results from relatively similar energy consumption (when normalised by market price).”

To account for the wild fluctuations in cryptocurrency price, and therefore effort expended by miners, the researchers used a median of all the values between 1 January 2016 and 30 June 2018, and attempted to account for the geographic dispersal of bitcoin miners.

“Any cryptocurrency mined in China would generate four times the amount of CO2 compared to the amount generated in Canada,” they write, highlighting the importance of such country-dependent accounting.

In the long term, the environmental impact of cryptocurrencies will vary not only with their market value, but also according to the adoption of new technologies.

The Ethereum project, for instance, has expressed an interest in moving from the energy intensive “proof of work” to a relatively untested alternative, “proof of stake”.

This story originally appeared in The Guardian. Image courtesy of Lars Hagberg/AFP/Getty Images.

Join The Discussion

Thailand Signals Shift In Refugee Policy After Rahaf Mohammed
Thailand Signals Shift In Refugee Policy After Rahaf Mohammed [Video]
Brexit Plans In Chaos After UK Parliament Rejects Proposal
Brexit Plans In Chaos After UK Parliament Rejects Proposal [Video]
Coming To Canada 'Worth The Risk,' Says Saudi Teen Refugee
Coming To Canada ‘Worth The Risk,’ Says Saudi Teen Refugee [Video]
Prime Minister Theresa May Tries To pull MPs Behind Brexit Deal
Prime Minister Theresa May Tries To Pull MPs Behind Brexit Deal [Video]
Is Bitcoin Building Support Above $3,500
Is Bitcoin Building Support Above $3,500?
Belarus Allows Traders To Buy Shares With Bitcoin
Belarus Allows Traders To Buy Shares With Bitcoin
US Government Shutdown Is Halting Crypto Progress On Wall Street
US Government Shutdown Is Halting Crypto Progress On Wall Street
I Made $1M On Bitcoin
I Made $1M On Bitcoin – And Lost It Again
40+ Video Marketing Statistics For 2019
40+ Video Marketing Statistics For 2019 [Infographic]
Emerging Email Marketing Trends To Survive 2019 And Beyond
Emerging Email Marketing Trends To Survive 2019 And Beyond [Infographic]
Visual Trends To Be Aware Of In 2019
Visual Trends To Be Aware Of In 2019 [Infographic]
How To Get Sponsored Posts For Your Blog
How To Get Sponsored Posts For Your Blog
4 Tips To Help You With The Constant Changes In Social Media
4 Tips To Help You With The Constant Changes In Social Media
Instagram's Testing Side-Scrolling Feed View, Similar To Stories
Instagram’s Testing Side-Scrolling Feed View, Similar To Stories
The 10 Best Instagram Tools For 2019
The 10 Best Instagram Tools For 2019
Pinterest's Recommendation Algorithms Are Improving
Pinterest’s Recommendation Algorithms Are Improving
What Is Your Therapist Listening For
What Is Your Therapist Listening For?
Wish You Were Smarter
Wish You Were Smarter? These 4 Brain Hacks Can Help You Get There
Weightlifting Less Than An Hour Per Week Could Increase Your Longevity
Weightlifting Less Than An Hour Per Week Could Increase Your Longevity
Your Environment May Affect Your Eyes More Than You Realize
Your Environment May Affect Your Eyes More Than You Realize
Thailand Signals Shift In Refugee Policy After Rahaf Mohammed
Thailand Signals Shift In Refugee Policy After Rahaf Mohammed [Video]
Brexit Plans In Chaos After UK Parliament Rejects Proposal
Brexit Plans In Chaos After UK Parliament Rejects Proposal [Video]
Coming To Canada 'Worth The Risk,' Says Saudi Teen Refugee
Coming To Canada ‘Worth The Risk,’ Says Saudi Teen Refugee [Video]
Prime Minister Theresa May Tries To pull MPs Behind Brexit Deal
Prime Minister Theresa May Tries To Pull MPs Behind Brexit Deal [Video]